|
| Title: A Scenario for Detective T-Dog | |
| historylovers > General > General Discussion | Go to subcategory： |
| Author | Content |
MarkUK
|
|
|
Date Posted：19/09/2021 07:27:16Copy HTML A man attacks his wife with a knife in their home, she is injured but escapes from the house pursued by her husband. She runs into the road but is struck by a car and killed. Is her husband guilty of murder? You're playing chess with Fate and Fate's winning.
Arnold Bennett
|
PBA-3rd-1949
|
Share to:
#1
|
|
Re：A Scenario for Detective T-Dog Date Posted：19/09/2021 07:55:30Copy HTML 19/09/2021 03:27:16 A man attacks his wife with a knife in their home, she is injured but escapes from the house pursued by her husband. She runs into the road but is struck by a car and killed. Is her husband guilty of murder. I would say yes. He was the direct cause of her death. |
|
tommytalldog
|
Share to:
#2
|
|
Re：A Scenario for Detective T-Dog Date Posted：19/09/2021 11:48:38Copy HTML 19/09/2021 03:27:16 A man attacks his wife with a knife in their home, she is injured but escapes from the house pursued by her husband. She runs into the road but is struck by a car and killed. Is her husband guilty of murder. I would say yes. He was the direct cause of her death. It is her fault for aggravating him to the point of him pulling a knife. |
shula
|
Share to:
#3
|
|
Re：A Scenario for Detective T-Dog Date Posted：19/09/2021 01:44:26Copy HTML If insurance money became involved, the company would certainly gain from a guilty verdict.
"It is forbidden to spit on cats in plague-time."
-Albert Camus-
|
|
PBA-3rd-1949
|
Share to:
#4
|
|
Re：A Scenario for Detective T-Dog Date Posted：20/09/2021 12:56:25Copy HTML 19/09/2021 03:27:16 A man attacks his wife with a knife in their home, she is injured but escapes from the house pursued by her husband. She runs into the road but is struck by a car and killed. Is her husband guilty of murder. I would say yes. He was the direct cause of her death. It is her fault for aggravating him to the point of him pulling a knife. Yes it's always the nagging wifes fault isn't it? Any judge will tell you that. |
|
majorshrapnel
|
Share to:
#5
|
|
Re：A Scenario for Detective T-Dog Date Posted：20/09/2021 06:25:38Copy HTML If men killed their wives every time they annoyed them there wouldn’t be any wives left. C’mon, let’s have it right, he sounds a right wanker, attack her with a knife? Isn’t that attempted murder in the first place? I’ve wanted to attack Pete with a knife a hundred times but you just don’t do things like that. |
|
tommytalldog
|
Share to:
#6
|
|
Re：A Scenario for Detective T-Dog Date Posted：20/09/2021 09:59:56Copy HTML If men killed their wives every time they annoyed them there wouldn’t be any wives left. C’mon, let’s have it right, he sounds a right wanker, attack her with a knife? Isn’t that attempted murder in the first place? I’ve wanted to attack Pete with a knife a hundred times but you just don’t do things like that. True Major, but not every man displays the self-restraint you are blessed with. |
|
majorshrapnel
|
Share to:
#7
|
|
Re：A Scenario for Detective T-Dog Date Posted：20/09/2021 12:48:58Copy HTML True Tom, but 3000 miles of ocean does tend to aid my sainthood somewhat. |
|
majorshrapnel
|
Share to:
#8
|
|
Re：A Scenario for Detective T-Dog Date Posted：20/09/2021 01:27:42Copy HTML Back to that less famous Thomas…… Cochrane. D’you know, in typical fashion he actually escaped from prison but instead of running off to hide or seek redress he went to Parliament and demanded his seat back. He was arrested and throw back in his cell. When he finally got out he was approached by representatives of Chile to take over their navy in their fight for independence from Spain. The rebels were doing very well on land but Spanish rule of the seas made full independence almost impossible. Cochrane accepted the post and sailed for Chile He was introduced to his command which was 1 tiny Sloop, three small Brigs and three frigates, including the 50 gun Bernardo O Higgins, which he took as his flagship. After sorting out his crews he set sail for the Spanish garrison town of Callao, only to find after setting sail that his 5 year old son had stowed aboard. The attack had a certain amount of farce about it because of fog and when his two leading ships approached the fortress of Callao their guns opened up, making his fellow ship turn and do a runner, whilst his son ran on board to see the excitement a sailor went to grab him only to have his head whipped off by a canon ball right next to him, so Cochrane was forced to beat a retreat. |
|
PBA-3rd-1949
|
Share to:
#9
|
|
Re：A Scenario for Detective T-Dog Date Posted：20/09/2021 09:22:51Copy HTML If men killed their wives every time they annoyed them there wouldn’t be any wives left. C’mon, let’s have it right, he sounds a right wanker, attack her with a knife? Isn’t that attempted murder in the first place? I’ve wanted to attack Pete with a knife a hundred times but you just don’t do things like that. True Major, but not every man displays the self-restraint you are blessed with. If he wore pants that fit him and less thong underwear, we wouldn't be able to call him Plumbers crack anymore. Never take a knife to a gun fight Arthur. |
|
tommytalldog
|
Share to:
#10
|
|
Re：A Scenario for Detective T-Dog Date Posted：21/09/2021 12:55:01Copy HTML 19/09/2021 03:27:16 A man attacks his wife with a knife in their home, she is injured but escapes from the house pursued by her husband. She runs into the road but is struck by a car and killed. Is her husband guilty of murder. I would say yes. He was the direct cause of her death. Direct cause? Is that what you got outta this scenario? |
